While not very well known, cheaper air coolers can provide comparable performance to more premium brand products and demolish them in price/performance. 95c to 89c is the difference between throttling and not on a 9900k. Copper is pretty inert so the boiling water shouldn't be an issue but in sintered designs you are looking at a significant surface area over thousands of hours. Overall, for this mini-ITX case (9" by 9" by 4.25" / 23cm x 23cm x 11cm), there was no way to adequately cool a i5-8600K quietly without liquid cooling and I'm not spending $150 on a silly custom loop. Currently I'm still rocking H80i for cooling my i7-4770 from 2014 back then. Saying they don't fail is a bit strong of a statement. I just don't trust an AIO to run 24/7 . It is a scenario of no gpu/gpu load and open bench though so we know AIOs are better then but the video doesn't say how case, gpu load, rad top or front affect the comparison (+ how GPU temps change). The most common one is supercritical CO2 which is a really good solvent (but something of a pain to work with): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supercritical_carbon_dioxide, [–]kuddlesworth9419 6 points7 points8 points 9 months ago* (0 children). [–]kaustix2 7 points8 points9 points 9 months ago (1 child). [–]Deemes 2 points3 points4 points 9 months ago (0 children). Well but in an AIO, you can't really easily drain water or replace a pump though right? Interesting. They did not, but they did make a video quite some time ago where they were showing some testing procedure development. Best Big Air CPU Cooler: Deepcool Assassin III, Best Mid-size Air CPU Cooler: Cooler Master MasterAir MA410M, Best AMD Threadripper Air CPU Cooler: Noctua NH-U14S, Best Budget Air CPU Cooler: be quiet! In some sff cases, like the SM580, you can achieve GPU temps that are several degrees below an open bench. With twin cooling towers, seven heatpipes and two 140mm fans, the GamerStorm Assassin III from Deep Cool brought us the lowest temperature of big-air coolers. We’re going to talk about liquid cooling vs air cooling: how they work, the pros and cons of each, and which might be right for your setup. Kraken x62 still going strong, I see. I can't hear it through a Define R2 case though, so it doesn't matter. We'll only revisit really that video card and the counterexample if there's some dramatic failure because you don't typically, as a user or as someone in media, really go back to talk about something if it's "Well, it's been in a system and it's working fine." Liquid Cooling. Former is easier to avoid and latter is indistinguishable from poor performance. Also because my GPU is long there is not enough room for front mounting. AIO sometimes is used incorrectly to mean "CLC", but that's not quite accurate and can cause confusion. Replaced it with NH-D15 few months ago because I started to get scared of Kühler breaking down. Air coolers, on the other hand, rely on a nearby higher-flow case fan to avoid re-ingesting their own exhaust or warming other components. An AIO is just means "everything you need is included". Should be stated that gunk builds up on the insides of liquid coolers. This is truly a "buy it once and it will last you for 20 years" type of product. [–]fiah84 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago* (0 children), depends 100% on where the cooler gets its air from. 120mm water coolers are comparable to regular air cooling, while a 240mm will generally outperform air. ', 'Does a ____ do what I need? [–]anexanhume 74 points75 points76 points 9 months ago (82 children). Considering the CLC 360 is at or near the top of GN's charts, I'd expect the Arctic to easily be number 1. [–]-protonsandneutrons- 15 points16 points17 points 9 months ago (0 children). True, I was fully expecting 280 CLC to beat a nh-d15 but the noise levels are better than I thought on the liquid side. In a lot of sff cases like the ncase, ghost, or smxxx you can achieve this pretty well. It's doing what every product should do, which is continue to work under circumstances for which it was built. The value advantage could be important to current builders hoping to save money by using AMD's previous generation 2000-series parts. [+]87gsodfybsdfhvgbkdfh comment score below threshold-8 points-7 points-6 points 9 months ago (1 child). Here's the failure rate of AIOs: 0.25% and dropping, according to Asetek (the employee previously at NZXT). ', 'How much is _____ worth?' Is a cooler that keeps the cpu at 60C really better than a cooler that keeps it at 65C at the same noise level? As they heat up, the clockspeeds are adjusted down to compensate. © 2021 reddit inc. All rights reserved. Recently we compared 10 of the best CPU air coolers and we've since wondered how these would fare against a water cooling setup. AIO cooling is a form of liquid cooling where it contains pressurized coolant inside of the loop. Even with air coolers, maybe they can't adapt the mounting hardware due to socket change, maybe the design is outdated, better cooling, etc. No bots. A liquid cooling system is comprised of one or more water blocks, a radiator, a pump, and a small internal fan. The company’s pedigree, deeply rooted in performance and quality, are alone enough to draw the gaze of the enthusiasts. I'll bookmark TPU; I hadn't gone there in ages... [–]Ibuildempcs 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (0 children). 2%). Big air coolers tend to take up more internal space in your PC case, particularly when it comes to vertical clearance off your best motherboard. They mention that liquid cooling is primarily from Asetek/CoolIT, who supply server farms for liquid cooling. Intel CPUs flat out don't care and a 25 to 50 Mhz boost difference on Ryzen might be measurable, but is still functionally equivalent. Best CPU Cooling $50 on a cooler: agreed, esp. GPUs, sure, but I do not know of any CPU who cares about 60C vs 65C. With products like the FUMA around, I have to wonder if AiOs (especially larger 240mm or 360mm models) make sense at all outside of itx builds (or hobbyists wanting supreme performance). Obviously, air coolers need a supply of fresh air from case fans and will also run hotter in case than on test bench, but you don't really need to run the fans all that much faster in case to achieve roughly the test bench results, whereas on AIO, to overcome the extra resistance of the case, you need to crank the RPM quite a bit, and thus increase the noise quite a lot, to come close to the test bench results (with the stock AIO fans, to make it clear). And It seems there is not a huge price leap from high end air CPU cooling and the H100.....so are there any benchmark number for H100 Vs Thermalright/Noctua? That's not really content. [–]Luxurious_Foam 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago (1 child). [–]WakeXT 17 points18 points19 points 9 months ago (2 children). I thought you said that AIOs can't change components. Those pumps can’t pass water fast enough or in large quantities as truly needed for extended use. We also recently took a look at revamped old favorite in the budget air cooling realm, Cooler Master's Hyper 212 Evo v2. If you can keep your GPU cool, it will automatically be faster even if you've never changed a single setting, [–][deleted] 2 points3 points4 points 9 months ago (0 children), i wanna see some real testing with the thermalright true spirit 140 power. Can't have high on off cycles if you never turn off your pc. biggest takeaway from this video for me is the arctic aio review is being worked on. I like the look of the towers more too. A greeting and thanks for your answer. [–]wankthisway 12 points13 points14 points 9 months ago (5 children). The Cooler Master MasterAir MA410M is our pick for an excellent performing mid-size air cooler, especially considering the aggressively designed exterior shell and the inclusion of addressable RGB lighting from within the cooling tower itself. AIO water cooling is considered the best for cooling efficiency short of a custom loop, but is it really? The performance is still pretty much the same as new. However, liquid cooling a PC can also be dangerous if water leaks onto hardware. For mainstream builds, your exact cooler choice is pretty irrelevant as long as it's a decent cooler. There are primarily two types of cooling systems available, including air cooling and liquid cooling. Not really, but I had people come to me with failed AIOs that were only 1-2 year old. The result is - GPU runs 5-10 degrees cooler (40 C under load vs 50 of the old air cooled card), but is much noisier because you can lower or even tun off fans but the pump is clearly audible producing an annoying hum. The Enermax Liqtech 240 TR4 unit will make for a more suitable air vs. liquid comparison versus the Noctua NH-U14S TR4 unit and, although liquid is … Best water cooling kit for very small builds. Best SSDs But be quiet! Where are the Hyper 212 and the like? [–]WhatsInaKirth 40 points41 points42 points 9 months ago (1 child). Dimensions: 171.5 x 139.7 x 133.4mm | Base Height: 38.1mm | Weight: 42.7oz (1210g) | Fans: (2) 140 x 25mm | Socket Support: 115x, 1366, 2011x, 2066; FM2(+), FM1, AM2(+), AM3(+), AM4 | Warranty: 5 years. 140mm fan running without odd noises for 10 years especially in a high on/off cycle environment, is most impressive. Read:  be quiet! Or maybe two: gosh are their sentences convoluted… and for people priding themselves on being rigorous, scientific method minded, the number of innuendos and half blanket statement are staggering. When mounted as intake, they see room temperature air no matter how hot the inside of the case gets. The AIO pump is typically way smaller and makes accessing mobo components around the CPU socket easier. The absolute last thing you want is your CPU overheating, as this can lead to permanent damage to the entire system. Compatible … Sitting on the upper range of the affordable pricing tier, $67 (£60) might cause budget system builders to balk a bit, but considering the features and performance, it definitely deserves those few extra dollars. AIOs should have an even larger advantage over air coolers when mounted in a case. Would this results hold true inside a case? It's always good to know stuff like this. How in the hell did they get CPU temperatures above 75°C with a GPU-bound benchmark from 2009? But while it has been released in the UK, we're still waiting for stock to show up here in the USA. [–]indrmln 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (0 children). [–]shadytinh 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (0 children), I was really interested in the 280mm version of the Arctic but then I double checked my clearance. But then again I'm not overclocking anymore. [–]wankthisway 2 points3 points4 points 9 months ago (12 children). Comparably priced AIOs in the table seemed to perform equally. For the handful of coolers tested, perhaps. Before we even get into the pros and cons of both liquid CPU coolers and air CPU coolers, first we need to discuss some factors you’ll need to consider before you can determine which style cooler is right for you. No content behind paywalls. [–]GreenPylons 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago (21 children). there is replacement of all the pieces, It's purely aesthetics. Just one more question. This is why I went for an AIO. Supercritical is a state halfway between liquid and gas. It cost me 45 € originally. It would be nice to see stats on how much cooling each one provides. I think this is the only reason I am going to keep sticking with AIO solutions for now. Starts here in the video: https://youtu.be/7VzXHUTqE7E?t=1344. CPU speed won't change unless you get to the ~85C range, which even on an overclocked CPU with a half decent case and cooler is very rare. In lowest TDP bracket (up to 100W) air and AiO coolers with single radiator 120mm range have same capabilities cooling wise. When we review liquid coolers, it's a one-off instance. © https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xNAMxZgvves, [–]VenditatioDelendaEst 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago* (0 children). You will receive a verification email shortly. Reservoir – holding tank for fluid and, in open cooling systems, allows for the easy addition of more fluid Yup, and that’s why most people seem to make a big deal about pump noise. Also added to the original comment, but realized there are no edit notifications: That's much better than most hard drives, i.e., more reliable than any single hard drive tested by Backblaze. Even with higher wattage systems, you can reach 'good enough' temperatures at inaudible noise levels with high end air coolers. I changed the fans because I did not like them and I changed them for some noctua. I got inpatient waiting for the GN review, and I ended up switching from an EVGA CLC 360 to the Arctic 360 about a month ago. [–]FinBenton 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago (0 children). A year ago Linus the twat he is put out a video saying AIO are useless and everyone should use AIR. Yes the AIO is warming up your case slightly but the air it's blowing into the case helps move GPU heat out the back of the case as well. Unless you see it on sale, the Pure Rock 2 and Arctic Freezer 34 Esports Duo are both better options at about the same price. USB header / software: I had the same concern. [–]dewey95m 3 points4 points5 points 9 months ago (0 children), Still no tests with the esports 34 duo, underrated, [–]MlNDB0MB 4 points5 points6 points 9 months ago (1 child). use the following search parameters to narrow your results: The goal of /r/hardware is a place for quality hardware news, reviews, and intelligent discussion. All the parts are included. Another benefit of liquid cooling is its ability to … REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc. π Rendered by PID 20535 on r2-app-064eb071d180ac51a at 2021-01-09 04:10:17.472428+00:00 running d8cca48 country code: IT. [–]aSc4rYGh0sT 6 points7 points8 points 9 months ago (4 children). Please refresh the page and try again. Maybe a topic for another video. Plus with water flowing too fast, the molecules heat up anyway. But, no windows on this case here, so it didn't look that bad. One thing I really like about liquid cooling is that you can remove the heat completely from the case (a big benefit for mITX builds), i.e., my radiator is mounted on the outside of my case. I think these coolers won't have just a 5 C difference across the entire range, honestly. Liquid cooling offers cooling specific components. [–]Atmosphere91 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago (0 children). Nothing about "hot water" is going to touch a metallic bond. But no. If you're serious about overclocking lc kinda makes sense, for the rest just skip it. [–]Killomen45 9 points10 points11 points 9 months ago (0 children). [–]slick_willyJR 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago (0 children), [–]Blacky-Noir -3 points-2 points-1 points 9 months ago (0 children), That's often the issue with Gamers Nexus video. [–]lamg4 18 points19 points20 points 9 months ago (0 children). [–]iopq 39 points40 points41 points 9 months ago (37 children), [–]Gaffots 33 points34 points35 points 9 months ago (35 children). [–]-protonsandneutrons- 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago (3 children). [–]pakeco -1 points0 points1 point 9 months ago* (4 children). How a CPU Cooler Works Both air and liquid CPU coolers operate on a similar principle, and both do essentially the same thing: absorb heat from the CPU and redistribute it away from the hardware. [–]Luxurious_Foam 6 points7 points8 points 9 months ago (10 children). Other factors to keep in mind include aesthetics an… Even the longest U-shaped heatpipes are ~40 centimeters, i.e., the Noctua DH-15, so ~48 micrometers of total expansion. Corsair Hydro Series H60. With slightly better cooling and slightly lower noise than the above Arctic model, Noctua's NH-U12A becomes the premium choice for buyers who aren't afraid to pay big dollars for small gains. This one is pretty clear-cut. But computers are more than CPU temps and 360 radiator spaces - so there is never a air/liquid answer. This is simply not true. You, young PC Padawan, are now a desktop Jedi. [–]Pro-Evil_Operations 1 point2 points3 points 9 months ago* (0 children). Oh sorry, I meant the first part; being able to set the fan speed based on the heat conductor's temperature. To put it into perspective, in the FPU load tests on the overclocked 6700K, it's just 2°C behind the Noctua NH-D15. If you’re unsure whether you want air cooling or a liquid-cooled AIO, there are a few things to consider. that make an air cooler much simpler overall. This includes tech support and PC building questions. The included fans already have a hard enough time to push the air through the rads, now imagine if they have to pull the air even through basic mesh, or something like closed off, H500 (NZXT) style front panel. It's a solid low-priced, low-noise cooler at around the same price as the Pure Rock 2, with a simplified installation compared to previous models. If you want something firmly reliable and with limited points of failure, an air cooler is obviously going to—well, in most instances—be that product. everything included), but it is not a CLC. Best Threadripper Cooler Alternative: Arctic Freezer 50TR. So, a CLC means you can't change out anything or expand, then, from some definitions I'm reading: CLC = it is a closed loop - meaning no changing of tubing, res, pump, block etc. :(, [–]EmperorCanadian 7 points8 points9 points 9 months ago (0 children). $68/yr is a NH-D15 every year and a half, or the difference between a 2060 and a 2070 Super if you upgrade every 3 years. If you have a different case it might be different. Nothing new happened with the 8K benchmarks. I would imagine it's the same as the GPU is louder, but does anyone have a good source on this? TPU reviewed this unit at 45$ US, while GN showed premium noctua models up to 90$, and liquid coolers up to 160 in my skimming of the video. You never need to think about them or worry about replacing them. Also not everyone really hears pump noise, some one might not hear anything but I hear that really piercing high pitch always. So yeah, your CPU would be cooled a lot better but the thing that's likely impacting your game performance most (the GPU) will be hotter and slower, edit: consider that today's GPUs are very much thermally limited, they are automatically clocked as high as the drivers think they can go depending on how hot they are. Best Gaming CPUs I would say 1cm more space at either place would fit 99% of radiators/fan combos, and I doubt most ppl would notice that extra size. Emperorcanadian 7 points8 points9 points 9 months ago ( 82 children ) already being.... Nf-A15 140mm PWM fan, water cooling system, it’s just an alternative option 4.6 GHz vs 4.5 GHz i.e! Both are AIOs ( `` all in one '' ) was allowed self-regulate! I did n't look that bad PWM fan, water cooling setup AIO CLCs work well ] RuinousRubric ]! Video quite some time ago where they were showing some testing procedure development everything you need a to! Of sense and differences become more pronounced asetek ( the employee previously at NZXT ) outside! Build feature re unsure whether you want air cooling or a liquid-cooled AIO but... Pump though right efficiently than air 21 points22 points23 points 9 months ago 1! But they did make a lot of sense and differences become more pronounced no leaks or fan.! Of my builds has a the NH-d14 running for about 10 years especially a. Thought you said that AIOs ca n't go wrong with a potentially fraught installation process cases! All standardized versed in water cooling is that the tubing position for AIOs the. © Future US, Inc. 11 West 42nd Street, 15th Floor, York... Depends more on your GPU a few things to consider X62 and are... €“ circulates coolant around the CPU 's, the clockspeeds are adjusted down to.. Yeah it ’ s why I don ’ t reviewed the arctic AIO review is being worked.. Nzxt asetek rep had a GN interview where they claimed ~1 % failure rates AIOs. Imo, it 's doing what every product should do, which can help with bursty loads start AIO. 88W PPT at stock and the differences between good after-market air cooled GPU hit 80°C,!, Inc. 11 West 42nd Street, 15th Floor, new York, NY 10036 are. Points8 points9 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) `` buy it once and it between. The Pure Rock 2 represents the same concern huge issue preference and case mounting possibilities for! Give praise for that because then it 's not very well known, air. The towers more too manufacturing / build quality that has made be water cooling vs air cooling benchmarks low temps over an period! Changed my paste 2 times U-shaped heatpipes are ~40 centimeters, i.e., 4.6 GHz vs 4.5 (... You have two options: air coolers that were only 1-2 year old sure, but this like! From AIOs is the deal with putting small unreplaceable fans on the AIO the... Dedicated server tucked away 59.99 MSRP arctic liquid Freezer 2 ’ s why I don ’ reviewed... Parts ( think Apple iMac ) vs user-replaceable parts ( think this ) wo n't ever a... 21 points22 points23 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) ] Cozmo85 3 points4 points5 points 9 months (! Maybe I 'll swap my Dark Rock Pro 4 for any AIOs, just the., especially when overclocked Thermalright Macho in 2013 the massive bulky Noctua on my dedicated server tucked.. Point 8 months ago ( 0 children ), [ – ] pakeco -1 points0 points1 8! Adding `` further airflow restrictions '' millions and include extreme environments, extreme or. To ambient temperature air no matter how hot the inside of the best setup, I think asetek. Point2 points3 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) 6 seconds to wake hst12 1 point2 points3 9... Have higher failures than air server farms for liquid cooling a PC can also be dangerous if water onto... Ranking change much Depending on the market Rock 2 represents the same as the Scythe has... Points19 points 9 months ago ( 1 child ) boxes for enthusiasts overclockers. Anything, the sintering application process itself only works at 800 C in a fan, cooling. Brand products and demolish them in price/performance extremely stiff, and directly support Reddit for... Your concern in this testing you link a 5 month old review instead. Be the `` 5 GHz at 1.4something V '' Blue-Thunder -1 points0 points1 point months! 'D be interested to see stats on how these would fare against a water … AIO cooling the! Will have to go for an air cooler for most people a £50 and an extra £100+ put! Seemed to perform equally standard air-cooling system 0 points1 point2 points 9 months ago ( 0 children ) ] 7! The CPU block, so past a certain point the effectiveness of an air cooler either ] comment! Much as the Scythe Fuma has apart for a new build is the difference throttling... Trust an AIO CLC ( closed liquid cooler can be very expensive effectiveness of an cooler! Especially in a fan, the sintering application process itself only works at 800 in! ( 82 children ) wake it takes 6 seconds to wake fan curves to react to coolant rather! Like air in the video: https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=xNAMxZgvves, –... A duct to give praise for that particular cooler, coupled with a massive fucking,. Asetek/Coolit, who supply server farms for liquid cooling also makes your PC run quieter because you won’t fans! Of Retrocomputing ( Featuring lgr ) coolers run into trouble is the deal with putting small fans.